I recently got the Final Crisis Companion (the last book I needed to complete my Final Crisis collection), and I've been re-reading the series and following this list (I'm about to start Revelations), and so far this list looks great. Unfortunately, my copies of Seven Soldiers of Victory are on loan to a friend, so I was not able to read those first; I was amazed at how much that series set up for Final Crisis though.

I think Requiem makes the most sense immediately after Final Crisis #1, and Rogue's Revenge does make sense building off of Libra's gathering of the villains.

I did skip R.I.P. because I recently re-read the Batman run leading up to it (I'll still read Last Rites, and since I only collect trades, I don't have DC Universe #0 (which is a shame, really, since I started reading the post-R.I.P. Outsiders, and that plays a significant part with Geo-Force).

Thanks for putting this together!