Submit Review

User Name (required)

Email (required)

Website (optional)

Book Title (required)

Review Text (required, HTML allowed)

Note: a good size is between 500 and 1000 words. Shorter reviews might not be accepted.
Longer is ok, if there is good reason!

Verdict (One or two sentences)

Essential Continuity? (Do we need to read this to understand the event or character? Feel free to elaborate!)

What should we read first? (full sentences please!)

What should we read next? (full sentences please!)

Review Pictures (Optional, jpg, png, and gif only)




If the form is not working, or if you already have your review saved in a .doc file (or similar format), feel free to email reviews@tradereadingorder.com directly.

All reviews are subject to editorial changes. We will handle formatting and putting in images, plus corrections for any small mistakes in grammar or spelling. If we think your review will benefit from any large changes, we’ll email you to chat about it before posting. Reviews are published to all our readers, so a standard of quality will be maintained.

Not every review will be published. If you are published, be proud! You are now a freelance writer specializing in independent sequential art criticism. Put it on that resume! And feel free to list Ian as a reference.

By hitting send, you are giving us permission to post your review to our website with full credit, a link to your profile here, and a link to your website (if given.) At this time, as a fan community, no one gets paid for reviews (even Ian!) You may, however, become eligible for certain giveaways and contests by submitting a review that gets posted.

Since reviews are posted to the blog under your user name, if you are not already registered for an account we will register one for you and email you a temporary password. Otherwise, the post will be linked to your existing account and listed on your profile page.