Up Down
Find This Book At:
Amazon (Softcover)
Amazon (Hardcover)
Half.com (Softcover)
Half.com (Hardcover)
Ebay (Search by Title)
Ebay (ISBN/Softcover)
Ebay (ISBN/Hardcover)
View our database entry
Includes Issues:Green Arrow: Year One 1-6
Issue Dates:September – November 2007
Creators:
, , , , ,

This review contains light spoilers. Skip To The Verdict? »

I was introduced to Green Arrow through a mutual friend, Jack Kirby. More specifically, The Green Arrow by Jack Kirby, now reprinted in a thin trade DC put out about 9 years ago, which contained an origin story for the emerald archer.

I’d read that story before, much earlier in my life, but I’ll never be able to exactly place when. It’s probably not the first origin for the character, who’s been around since 1941, but it was an origin that was simple, easy, and cemented early Green Arrow in my mind as that slightly goofier Batman – he had an assistant, a car, an arrow signal, and fought crime, but without the darkness that came with Batman‘s alleyway trauma.

This goofiness, the fact that his millionaire playboy personality was represented in his costumed persona as much as out of it, unlike Bruce Wayne, made his shift to social crusader in the Bronze Age all the more interesting. He really grew as a character, hit rock bottom and built his way back into his own type of hero – no longer  in Batman’s shadow, but filling a spot in the DC Universe that was entirely his own.

To me, he became a symbol, the first real Modern Age hero. This was what happened when a cookie cutter bad guy basher of the Golden Age opened his eyes and saw the real problems in the world around him.

Now, Green Arrow’s origin gets a retelling courtesy of writer Andy Diggle and artist Mark Simpson (most commonly credited as the monosyllabic “Jock.”) They’re here to bring Green Arrow to a new audience, give a clear modern starting point to this contemporary Robin Hood.

As we’ve mentioned before (in our Teen Titans: Year One review) this is a fairly monumental task, not only to create a work that respects continuity enough to encourage readers to move on to the other existing titles, but also to stand up to the Year One label and the inevitable comparisons it draws to the Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli’s legendary Batman revitalization. Diggle and Jock are quick to rise to the challenge, both talented and experienced creators coming fresh off a large project together (The Losers.)

What they’ve come up with is sure to draw in new readers and please many Green Arrow fans. Here, Oliver Queen (already sporting a hint of the facial hair that will come to be a bit of a trademark) is taken forcefully from his life of unfulfilling excess and thrust into a battle for his life on an abandoned island.

The island is from the original origin, always a great excuse for him to develop his excellent skills as an archer. But unlike the earlier story, this one is tinted with intrigue and darkness from the start. Instead of simply accidentally falling overboard and having to hunt for survival, the battle here ends up being much more literal, and Queen is exposed early to horrors that plant the seeds for his latter strength of character.

The story is told at a brisk pace, hopping and skipping through Oliver’s long stay on the island and the events that follow.

It doesn’t feel rushed, but obviously a castaway story in 160 pages isn’t going to play out at the same pace for the entire book.

The climax and ending are extremely satisfying, and along the way all the pieces fall into place – including some excellent foreshadowing for “future” character development in the Bronze Age series.

Through all of it, Jock lends a vibrant atmosphere to a fairly dark tale.

The closest thing I could compare it to would be Far Cry, a videogame where you find yourself stalking through a jungle. It is, of course, much more beautifully rendered (Far Cry is probably quite dated now), but those who have played the game should get an immediate idea of what I’m referring to – a world that’s brutal and bloody, yet also unyielding beautiful.

Take that and pass it through Jock’s talented hands and you get a stylized rendering of fight sequences that could top any in a five star action movie. His work here isn’t quite as amazing as some of the covers I’ve seen him do for Batman books, but it tells the story clearly at all times – the sometimes vagueness of the backgrounds is contrasted by the perfect amount of detail on the faces to secure appreciation of expression.

It helps that David Baron has done such a spectacular job with this book’s colors. He brings just the exact right tints and shades of oranges, greens, purples and blues. It’s really beautiful work and ties the story together. When the last page is reached, just by the colors, it’s a different world, the start of a new story.

If I have any qualms about the book at all, its that it perhaps does one goal too well – with Oliver Queen built into the character he will later become, suddenly there is a large period in his (publishing history) life that becomes unexplainable. He has seen intense loss and known great debt through this journey, so how does one explain the return to playboy life between his origins and the Green Arrow / Green Lantern series?

If he is already the Modern Age crusader we love, what happens to the fall from grace and opening to a new perspective that made him so interesting? Without his Golden Age career, did he ever really have a change of heart about what a superhero should be?

If anything, the end of this book seems to leave Green Arrow closer to being a clone of Batman (maybe modern Batman this time) than he has been in years – the aforementioned last panel could be a Batman panel, just switch the costume and weapon. This is probably something that would trouble a long time fan much more than a new reader, however – because most new readers will probably skip all the pre-crisis material altogether and go into one of Green Arrow’s modern ongoings.

For them, this condensed version (where his growth as a person is also moved into his origin as a superhero, instead of coming later) may be just what they need.

Hopefully they will come to love the character as much as the rest of us, and then his historical roots will intrigue them.

There’s no wrong way to get into Green Arrow.

Verdict:
4 out of 5. A blockbuster action movie (Die Hard on the beach!) slammed into the origin of a cult favorite hero – and it works. Fantastic art and a very enjoyable story. My only misgivings are based on how this rethinking of the origin effects such a long running character, but for new readers these issues will probably be non-existent.

Essential Continuity:
Let’s say yes: this is Green Arrow’s modern age origin story.

Read first:
To get the origin I’m personally more familiar with, check out The Green Arrow by Jack Kirby, mentioned earlier. But I actually think it can be read after.

Read next:
As I said above, the Jack Kirby book can be read after, since it takes place when Green Arrow is already operative as a hero. Also, since you will probably BE a Green Arrow fan after this book, you’ll have more reason to seek it out.

After that, if you’re not already making your way down the entire Green Arrow Reading Order, you should at least pick up Green Lantern / Green Arrow: Volume 1 and Volume 2, which were extremely important Bronze Age publications, before making your way to his modern age ongoing collections.

« Back to the top?

http://www.tradereadingorder.com/character/green-arrow/
Join the forum discussion on this post
Want to stay up to date? Click here to subscribe to updates by RSS!
You can also sign up to get updates by Email!
« | »

9 Comments Post New »

  1. avatar Drakul wrote on at November 22, 2010 5:15 pm:

    I grabbed this book a NYCC this year. I’m curious about the character but i’m not sure I want to go deep into it.
    I already have Longbow Hunters which I really like and I also bought Quiver to test it out. I heard the first 2-3 volumes were good but after that it was so-so.

    I may pick up the Green Lantern / Green Arrow since I love the Batman Illustrated by Neal Adams.

    [Reply]

    avatar Ian replied on November 22nd, 2010 at 6:42 pm:

    It’s well worth getting those Neal Adams collections.

    Longbow Hunters was also good, I thought. There’s a few random appearances of him in year one era stuff (JLA Year One and The Ring The Arrow and the Bat) that are kind of hard to place due to issues I’ve talked about here.

    [Reply]

    avatar Drakul replied on November 23rd, 2010 at 9:39 am:

    I plan to pick up JLA Year One someday because as a fairly casual DC reader Year Ones are nice :)
    The Ring, the Arrow and the Bat I’ve never been really interested in. I can’t remember reading any great reviews on it either.

    [Reply]

    avatar Ian replied on November 23rd, 2010 at 6:56 pm:

    It’s an ok book, an easy introduction like you said, but not particularly spectacular.

    I may wait to review that one until I’ve had a chance to dip into the original origins of the jla, which I still haven’t read.

    [Reply]

  2. avatar duncanpr wrote on at December 16, 2010 11:19 pm:

    There are a few writing/illustrating teams that grab my attention as much as Diggle/Jock. After reading through some of these “Year One” reviews, I’m getting interested in picking some of them up. It seems they might make a nice break from the series I’m currently collecting.

    [Reply]

    avatar Ian replied on December 16th, 2010 at 11:21 pm:

    The Batgirl one is probably my favorite. While none of them have been truly terrible, it’s the only one that lived up to Batman: Year One. It wasn’t as dark and “meaningful” perhaps, but it was a lot more fun, so they kind of balance out.

    I have to reread the Robin one, but I’ll get to all of them sooner rather than later, I think.

    [Reply]

  3. avatar how to make water vapor cigarettes wrote on at April 26, 2014 6:28 am:

    fantastic points altogether, you simply gained a new reader.
    What might you suggest about your submit that yoou simply made some days ago?
    Any positive?

    [Reply]

  4. avatar how to lower blood pressure naturally wrote on at June 28, 2014 3:17 pm:

    * Ethnicity – high blood pressure tends to
    affect African Americans with greater frequency. Today many
    people take medications to lower or fix their blood pressure problems.
    Essential hypertension is the name for high blood pressure with no identifiable cause, and this actually accounts for the
    majority of cases.

    [Reply]

Trackbacks and Related Posts

Content from other blogs and on this site that links back to this post.
  1. Review: Batgirl: Year One | Trade Reading Order
    Pingback on at December 14, 2010 4:44 pm:

    [...] the challenge inherent in creating Year One books in our reviews for Teen Titans: Year One and Green Arrow: Year One.The creative team (authors Scott Beatty and Chuck Dixon, along with penciler Marcos Martin and [...]

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Registered users may edit their comments past the 5 minute limit. [Register] [Login] [Logout]
HTML is allowed, but posts containing more than two links or sketchy code will be held for moderation.

« | »